Why Credit Training Should Be Built Backwards From the Job
Most credit training is a library organized by topic. Ours starts from what a new analyst must be able to do alone by the end of month three, then works backwards to the courses.
Credit training works better when it starts from the job. Instead of a library of topics, Shockproof asked its credit experts what a new analyst must be able to do alone by the end of month three, then sequenced the courses backwards from that list, so each step builds on the one before it.
One Question for the Credit Experts
I’ve never worked in a commercial bank. When we rebuilt the Shockproof curriculum, that limited what I could contribute to one useful question, and I asked it of people who know the answer: what does a new credit analyst have to be able to do, alone, by the end of month three?
Most Training Is a Library
Most credit training is organized by topic: a course on cash flow, a course on collateral, one on ratios, one on covenants. You browse and pick what sounds relevant. A library works when you already know what you’re looking for. A new analyst doesn’t, so the order is left to chance.
A new analyst doesn’t yet know that spreading the statements has to come before the ratios, or that a ratio means little until you understand where the cash went.
The result is a catalog that is complete and hard to use. Every topic is there. The order isn’t.
Start With the Work, Then Build the Training
Instructional designers call the alternative job-task analysis: describe the work first, then build the training that produces it. Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe made a version of it well known in schools as “backward design” in Understanding by Design (1998). Decide what the learner should be able to do, how you’d know, then plan the lessons.
For us the “what” came from the credit experts: Patti Alexander, Tom Halupnik and Liz Pham, who together bring more than 100 years of hands-on banking experience. Their list of what a competent analyst does unassisted was short: spread a set of financial statements, reconstruct cash flow from them, read an industry well enough to know what can go wrong, write a credit memo that survives committee, and spot a loan going sideways before it’s obvious.
None of those is a topic. Each is a task that pulls on several topics at once. Spreading statements needs accounting. Reconstructing cash flow needs accounting plus an understanding of working capital. The memo needs all of it, plus judgment about what matters.
Sequencing Is the Real Design Decision
Once you have the jobs, most of the order falls out. You can’t reconstruct cash flow until you can read a balance sheet, and you can’t judge a loan structure until you know what the structures are. That is why Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders comes first and Commercial Lending Fundamentals comes second.
Commercial Lending Fundamentals stops, on purpose, before ratios, coverage and projections. Those belong in the underwriting paths, once the analyst has the vocabulary to use them well.
Inside a path the same logic runs at a smaller scale. Each course builds on the one before, and the work is done on cases with full financials, because the job is working on files.
Vygotsky and the Zone Just Past What You Can Do Alone
Lev Vygotsky, the Soviet psychologist, described the zone of proximal development: the space between what a learner can do alone and what they can do with help. That is where learning happens. Below it, the learner coasts. Above it, they’re lost, and lost learners quit. Sequencing is how a curriculum keeps someone in that zone.
Each step should be reachable from the last one with some support, and each step should take a little support away. In credit training that often looks like a worked example, then a partly worked one, then a new case the learner does on their own.
I’ve come to think a well-sequenced path is mostly a set of decisions made by people who have done the job and remember what was hard about it. That isn’t me. It’s the credit experts, and the method Rex Beach built at Wells Fargo that much of our cash flow teaching still rests on.
What It Cost
Building backwards is slower than writing a library. A course on collateral can’t be written in isolation: you have to know which case it supports, what came before it and what comes next. When the order of a path changes, several courses change with it, and good material sometimes gets left out.
Something that matters a great deal to a senior lender may not belong in a new analyst’s first three months. Cutting it is uncomfortable.
What This Means If You Manage Analysts
The useful question isn’t which courses a new hire should take. It’s what they should be able to do alone by month three, and in what order they’ll learn it. Write that list down for your own team. It will tell you more about your training than any catalog.
If you want more on why the problem should come before the concept, I wrote about Malcolm Knowles and adult learning in Adults Need the Problem Before the Concept. For a new hire’s view of how lending fits together, see How Commercial Lending Works, and How New Hires Learn to Think Like a Lender.
Where to Start
For a new analyst, the sequence starts with Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders, then Commercial Lending Fundamentals. Both are built from short modules and cases with full financials. If the order looks wrong from where you sit, tell me. The credit experts would rather fix it now.
Start Where the Job Starts
Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders is the first path for new banking professionals, followed by Commercial Lending Fundamentals.
Explore Accounting & Finance FoundationsFrequently Asked Questions
What is backward design in training?
Backward design starts from the result: decide what the learner should be able to do, decide how you’d know they can do it, and only then plan the lessons. Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe made the idea well known in Understanding by Design (1998).
What should a new credit analyst be able to do by month three?
Shockproof’s credit experts listed five jobs: spread a set of financial statements, reconstruct cash flow from them, read an industry well enough to know what can go wrong, write a credit memo that survives committee, and spot a loan going sideways before it’s obvious.
Which learning path should a new analyst take first?
Start with Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders, then Commercial Lending Fundamentals. Commercial Lending Fundamentals stops before ratios, coverage and projections on purpose; those come in the underwriting paths, once the analyst has the vocabulary to use them.
More From the Blog
Last updated November 4, 2026.