Desirable Difficulties: Why Training That Feels Easy Doesn’t Stick
Robert and Elizabeth Bjork’s research on desirable difficulties explains why smooth training fades, and why every Shockproof module ends with a question instead of a recap.
Desirable difficulties are conditions that make training feel slower and harder but produce learning that lasts: spacing, interleaving, varied practice, generating answers and testing. Robert and Elizabeth Bjork’s research shows that smooth, easy training can look good in the session while producing weaker long-term learning, which is why every Shockproof module ends with a question.
The Most Uncomfortable Finding in Training
The smoother a training video feels, the less of it you may remember a few weeks later. That isn’t my opinion. It comes from decades of research by Robert Bjork and Elizabeth Bjork at UCLA, and it is the most uncomfortable finding I know of for anyone who makes training. That includes us.
Performance Is Not Learning
The Bjorks draw a line between performance during training and learning that lasts. Performance is what you can do right now, in the session, with the material fresh. Learning is what you can still do weeks later, in a different setting, with nothing in front of you. The two can move in opposite directions.
Conditions that make performance look good during training, like practicing one thing at a time in a block and finishing with a tidy recap, can produce weaker long-term learning. Conditions that make training feel slower and harder can produce stronger learning.
The Illusion of Competence
Easy training produces a feeling of fluency. You follow the narrator, every step makes sense, and you’d swear you have it. What you have is recognition: you can recognize a correct answer when you see one. The job asks for recall, which is a different and harder thing.
Watching someone spread a set of statements and walk through the cash flow is very different from doing it yourself on a new file at 4 p.m. with a memo due. The first feels like learning. The second is what the bank needs.
This is also why a learner’s own sense of how well a session went is a weak guide to what they will remember. Ratings and reviews matter to us. We just don’t treat a good feeling at the end of a video as evidence of learning.
What the Bjorks Mean by Desirable Difficulties
In their short, readable chapter “Making Things Hard on Yourself, But in a Good Way” (2011), the Bjorks describe several kinds of difficulty that tend to help: spacing practice out, interleaving different kinds of problems, varying the conditions, generating an answer before being shown it, and testing yourself instead of rereading.
The word “desirable” matters. A difficulty helps when the learner can overcome it with effort. Difficulty that comes from confusion is not desirable: a cluttered slide, a narrator reading the slide aloud, a concept that depends on background the learner doesn’t have yet. Those just get in the way. That is why we also follow Richard Mayer’s principles on the screen itself, which I wrote about in Three Rules From Richard Mayer We Apply to Every Training Slide.
| Difficulty | What it means |
|---|---|
| Spacing | Spreading practice out over time instead of cramming it into one sitting |
| Interleaving | Mixing different kinds of problems instead of doing ten of the same kind in a row |
| Varying the conditions | Practicing in different contexts and with different examples |
| Generation | Trying to produce an answer before being shown it |
| Testing | Pulling an answer from memory instead of rereading it |
What It Changed in How We Build Modules
The clearest change is how a module ends. Ending with a summary is easy and satisfying. Ending with a problem (“here’s the balance sheet; which of these three things happened?”) is a little annoying, and it works better. We chose annoying: every module ends with a learning check you have to answer, and every course ends with a quiz.
Learners can retake any course or quiz as many times as they need, and a retake draws fresh questions from a pool. If the questions repeated, a learner could pass by recognizing them, which is exactly the illusion we’re trying to avoid.
The cases matter too. A case with full financials asks the learner to find the problem, not to watch someone else find it. That is generation, and it is slower than watching.
The Cost
I’ll admit this is a hard thing to sell. “Our training is slightly more frustrating on purpose” isn’t much of a tagline. Some learners find it irritating, especially the ones who are good at following along. They breeze through the narration and then miss the learning check.
That moment is the illusion of competence being corrected, which is the point, but it doesn’t feel good.
We’re in the business of people being able to analyze a borrower six months after the course. Feeling good at the end of the video is a different goal.
What a Manager Can Do With This
You don’t need a training platform to use the Bjorks’ work. Ask a new analyst to explain a cash flow to you without their notes. Have them spread a file before they see anyone else’s spread of it. Bring back a file they worked on a few weeks ago and ask what they’d do differently.
Each of these will feel harder to the analyst than reading another credit memo. That is a reasonable sign it’s working.
For the other half of the argument, why adults learn best when the problem comes first, see Adults Need the Problem Before the Concept.
Where to Try It
To see what a module that ends with a question feels like, start with Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders, the first path for new banking professionals, or try a free sample module. And if you want the research itself, read the Bjorks’ 2011 chapter. It’s short, and a little humbling.
Try a Module That Ends With a Question
Accounting & Finance Foundations for Lenders is 24 short modules, each ending with a learning check, built for new banking professionals.
Explore Accounting & Finance FoundationsFrequently Asked Questions
What are desirable difficulties?
Desirable difficulties are learning conditions that feel harder in the moment but improve long-term retention, a term from Robert and Elizabeth Bjork’s research. Examples include spacing, interleaving, varying the conditions, generating answers before seeing them, and testing yourself instead of rereading.
Why does easy training feel effective?
Smooth training produces fluency: the learner follows every step and recognizes the right answer when it appears. Recognition feels like knowing, but the job asks for recall on a new file, which easy training doesn’t practice.
Are all difficulties desirable?
No. A difficulty helps when the learner can overcome it with effort. Confusion caused by a cluttered slide, a narrator reading on-screen text aloud or missing background knowledge just gets in the way.
More From the Blog
Last updated November 4, 2026.